Creators and predators

A piece in the Guardian distinguishes between two sides of modern capitalism: the creative, beneficial side (more or less) and the predatory side. Somewhat simple, but also more balanced than ideologues would have it.

Understanding capitalism is in some ways simple. At its best, capitalism rewards creators, makers and providers: the people and firms that create valuable things for others, like imaginative technologies and good food, cars and drugs. Its moral claim is to provide an alternative to the predatory, locust-like tendencies of states and feudal rulers. It rewards the people who work hard and innovate, and by doing so makes everyone better off – more than any other economic system in history.

But capitalism also rewards takers and predators, the people and companies who extract value from others without contributing much in return. Predation is part of the everyday life of capitalism, in sectors as mainstream as pharmaceuticals, software and oil – where people’s money, their data, their time and their attention are routinely taken in fundamentally asymmetrical exchanges. It’s commonplace in the behaviour of slum landlords and loan sharks, and a large proportion of financial activity exploits asymmetries to capture, rather than create, value.

This distinction sets up the following diagnosis of our current situation:

The crisis we’re still living with resulted from too much predation and not enough creation – a vast extraction of value from the real economy by finance that coincided with a failure to feed new sources of growth in science, entrepreneurship and creativity.

If we can partner and influence the genuinely creative with Dhamma, we’ll have a chance of Dhammic society. (Dhamma and the predation won’t ever fit, except in the delusion of groups like Wat Phra Dhammakaya.) For someone like me who tends to emphasize the selfishness of capitalism, this offers some hope for our predicament.

You can read the whole piece here.

This entry was posted in Dhamma, General, Social Observations & Commentary. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Creators and predators

  1. wanderer63 says:

    Hi santi.

    Hmm…how’s about Dharmma capitalism?
    From this aspect, the beneficial side, the predatory side, the takers and the predators seem to have something in common. Need more and more. But where is the real/ genuine creative? Dharmma should be for free. But it that possible in this capitalist world now? (it’s impossible even in the practical way.) 🙂
    We already heard about spiritual fever. Forever book shopping and hunting/searching and practicing (temporary retreat as a fashion) in vain. This reminds me of the words in Ecclesiastes (which sounds very Tao to me): Vanity of vanities…all is vanity!
    Change is inevitable. But on one knows in which way. As someone said, “I am not too young to know everything any more.” Real Dharmma needs to hide? Real Dharmma society need to be secluded, to be survive?

    Will in be worst before it will be better and best?
    We have lived in capitalist world for too long to believe in that any more. 🙂

Leave a Reply